Sunday, December 18, 2005

Interesting Booker Development

If I may be permitted to geek out over my love of sentencing jurisprudence, the Ninth Circuit on Friday said that post-Booker appeals from a guideline departure should be reviewed by the abuse of discretion standard instead of the statutory de novo review under the Guidelines.

This means that once a judge authorizes a downward departure for a criminal defendant, it will be a lot harder for the government to have it reversed on appeal.

The case is US v. Menyweather. Check it out for a good overview of post-Booker sentencing procedure.

No comments: